Health Resources

Yes, You Can Have the Pie

November 12, 2026
Family and friends enjoying thanksgiving Meal

A practical guide to enjoying Thanksgiving with diabetes

Turkey and dressing. Sweet potatoes. Green beans. A slice of pie.

For many Middle Tennessee families, Thanksgiving just wouldn’t feel like Thanksgiving without the dishes that have been passed around the table for generations. If you’re living with diabetes, though, a holiday built around food can leave you wondering how much of that tradition still belongs on your plate.

The good news? Managing diabetes doesn’t mean giving up the foods you look forward to all year.

Megan McCauley, MD, FACE, an endocrinologist with Highpoint Health - Sumner with Ascension Saint Thomas , recommends a simple approach that lets patients enjoy their favorite foods while keeping portions in check.

“What I tell patients is to use a tablespoon to serve themselves rather than a large serving spoon. That way, they get a reasonable portion of what they want to eat without overdoing it." - Megan McCauley, MD, FACE, Highpoint Health - Sumner with Ascension Saint Thomas

That means the dressing can stay. So can the sweet potatoes.

And yes, you can have the pie.

A Helpful Place to Start

The American Diabetes Association recommends using a 9-inch plate and filling half with non-starchy vegetables, one-quarter with lean protein and one-quarter with quality carbohydrate foods.

Thanksgiving may look a little different, and that’s OK. Dressing, sweet potatoes, rolls and dessert all contain carbohydrates, so choose the foods you really want and keep portions reasonable.


A Southern Thanksgiving Menu

Now, let’s get to the food. These diabetes-friendly and dietitian-reviewed recipes bring familiar Thanksgiving flavors to the table, from savory dressing to pecan pie.

Note: Food images in this section were generated using AI for illustrative purposes. Actual recipe appearance may vary.

Herb-Roasted Turkey

Herb-Roasted Turkey (American Diabetes Association | Diabetes Food Hub)

Serves 12 | Serving size: 3 ounces, skinless

Fresh sage, thyme and rosemary give this turkey breast plenty of classic Thanksgiving flavor.

Per serving: 230 calories | 2g carbohydrates | 40g protein | 4g total fat | 250mg sodium

Get the recipe:  Herb-Roasted Turkey 

Sweet Home Sausage-Pear Dressing

Sweet Home Sausage-Pear Dressing (Diabetes Self-Management)

Serves 8 | Serving size: ¾ cup

Cornbread keeps this dressing rooted in Southern Thanksgiving tradition, while turkey sausage, celery, onion and pear give it a savory-sweet flavor.

Per serving: 134 calories | 13g carbohydrates | 5g protein | 7g total fat | 2g saturated fat | 356mg sodium | 1g fiber

Get the recipe:  Sweet Home Sausage-Pear Dressing

Green Beans with Cranberries and Hazelnuts

Thanksgiving Green Beans with Cranberries and Hazelnuts (American Diabetes Association | Diabetes Food Hub)

Serves 10 | Serving size: ½ cup

Fresh green beans get a Thanksgiving upgrade with tart cranberries, lemon zest and toasted hazelnuts.

Per serving: 40 calories | 6g carbohydrates | 1g protein | 2g total fat | 35mg sodium | 2g fiber

Get the recipe:  Thanksgiving Green Beans with Cranberries and Hazelnuts

Heart-Healthy Sweet Potato Bake with Pecan Topping

Heart-Healthy Sweet Potato Bake with Pecan Topping (Health eCooks)

Serves 12
Per serving:
225 calories | 5g fiber | 178mg sodium

This dietitian-reviewed sweet potato bake uses the natural sweetness of sweet potatoes with warm spices and a crunchy pecan topping. Health eCooks identifies the recipe as appropriate for both diabetic and heart-healthy eating plans.

Get the recipe: Easy Heart-Healthy Sweet Potato Bake with Pecan Topping 

Low-Sugar Pecan Pie with Maple Syrup

Low-Sugar Pecan Pie with Maple Syrup (Milk & Honey Nutrition)

Serves 10 | Serving size: 1 slice
Per serving:
401 calories | 36g carbohydrates | 5g protein | 27g fat | 24g sugar

Developed by diabetes dietitian Mary Ellen Phipps, MPH, RDN, LD, this Southern favorite skips corn syrup and uses maple syrup and coconut sugar.

Get the recipe: Low Sugar Pecan Pie with Maple Syrup (No Corn Syrup)

Whether it's a slice of pecan pie or another holiday favorite, Thanksgiving is about enjoying the foods and traditions that bring us together. 

"I often tell my patients that your health is shaped by what you eat most of the time, not by a single Thanksgiving meal," said Wanda Sims, a registered dietitian and certified diabetes educator at Highpoint Health - Sumner. "Enjoy your meal. Focus on smaller portions of your favorite foods. Tomorrow, get back on track."

A Little Support Goes a Long Way

Highpoint Health offers diabetes and nutrition education services, including:

  • Diabetes education classes covering healthy eating, blood sugar monitoring and medication management.
  • Individual nutrition counseling with a registered dietitian.
  • Free monthly diabetes support group meetings at Highpoint Health – Riverview

Diabetes and nutrition education programs are available at Highpoint Health – Sumner and Riverview. A physician’s order is required for education services. 

To find a provider, visit our Find a Doctor tool or call 800.424.DOCS (3627).

Learn more: Highpoint Health Diabetes Care

 


 

 

 

Read All Posts